Your Business Reputation Is Tanking. Now What?

By Kristen Ridout | August 7, 2025

Your business reputation isn’t just a star rating or number on a page – its a measurement of how your customers feel about you.

It’s hard not to take it personally.

Let’s be honest – this isn’t who you are.

The ratings hurt, the comments feel disconnected, and despite your team’s best efforts, something still isn’t resonating. But this isn’t just a business reputation issue. It’s a relationship issue.

The strategic marketing team at OTM of Fort Collins Colorado says this. “Fostering genuine relationships with customers is essential for successful reputation management, but so is investing in the customer experience, responding quickly to queries or complaints, and improving the overall service offering.“

Business Reputation is formed in the space between intention and experience – where people are either seen, known, valued, and loved… or not. When that gap grows, trust breaks.

Here’s the good news: trust can be rebuilt.

Reputation is responsive. It’s shaped by the way you show up, and how you respond when things go wrong. The good news? You can rebuild. But where do you start?

Lets explore some of the foundational elements of managing your online reputation.

Top Places People Check Your Business Reputation Online

Most online shoppers do some kind of reputation check before they ever buy from you – and the digital breadcrumbs they find are shaping how they feel about your brand long before they enter the checkout flow.

Here’s where they typically go:

  • Google – Your Business Profile and review average is one of the first things to show up in a search
  • Yelp – Especially powerful for service-based businesses, Yelp reviews heavily influence local discovery and purchasing decisions, often appearing high in search results.
  • Amazon or Shopify Product Reviews – If you’re selling on a platform, this is prime territory for user generated content
  • Trustpilot, Sitejabber, BBB – Third-party review aggregators that often carry more weight than your own site
  • Reddit, Facebook, Instagram, TikTok – Social listening here reveals what real people are saying about your brand, both directly and in niche communities
  • YouTube and Influencer Content – A single video review can be make-or-break for a shopper on the fence
  • Glassdoor and Indeed – Even your employer brand plays into how consumers trust your company

If you’re not checking all these places regularly, your online reputation is being shaped without your input.

How to Find Out What’s Hurting your Business Reputation

You can’t fix what you don’t understand. Don’t jump straight to solutions before you understand what the problem actually is. Here are some strategies to find out wht is hurting your online reputation.

1. Review aggregation and monitoring

Start by gathering what’s already being said about you publicly.

  • Google Business Profile, Yelp, Trustpilot, BBB, Sitejabber – Check star ratings, review volume, and recurring themes
  • Platform-specific reviews – Amazon, Shopify, and App Store

What to look for: average rating trends, repeated praise or complaints, and whether you’re responding to feedback

2. Social listening

Use tools or manual checks to explore what people are saying when you’re not in the room.

  • Monitor mentions on Reddit, Facebook, Instagram, TikTok, and X
  • Look at hashtags, community groups, and niche forums

What to look for: tone of conversation, emerging frustrations, and who is shaping the conversation.

3. Customer feedback loops

Go beyond public reviews to learn directly from your audience.

  • Send NPS surveys or quick post-purchase questionnaires
  • Review customer service logs, email replies, and chat transcripts
  • Follow up with lapsed customers to learn why they didn’t come back

What to look for: friction points, unmet expectations, and opportunities to make people feel seen, known, valued, and loved.

4. Search results audit

Search your brand and products in incognito mode.

  • Look for negative articles, outdated content, or poor reviews
  • Notice what ranks highest – you or someone else?

What to look for: whether you’re leading the narrative or trying to catch up to it.

5. Watch your performance metrics

Business reputation issues often show up in the numbers first.

  • Conversion rates, repeat purchases, and customer acquisition cost
  • Cart abandonment, bounce rate, and organic traffic trends

What to look for: sudden changes or gradual declines that signal deeper trust issues.

Look for patterns. Are the same pain points showing up again and again? Is there a specific product, process, or promise that’s misfiring?

What Causes Business Reputation Decline?

Let’s move past surface-level speculation and get into the real contributors to low company reviews, and net promoter score drops.

Here’s what we see most often:

  • Inconsistent product quality: Look for return rates, defect reports, and negative user generated content. If the product doesn’t match the promise, word spreads fast
  • Shipping and delivery issues: Delays, damaged goods, incorrect orders – it all chips away at trust
    • Track fulfillment KPIs like late shipment rate, error frequency, and delivery experience
  • Unhelpful or impersonal customer service: Long hold times, robotic scripts, or lack of resolution are a major NPS killer. Monitor support CSAT, average resolution time, and feedback after tickets
  • Mismatch between marketing and reality: This happens when the story you’re telling isn’t the one your customers live. Do an experience audit comparing what you promise with what gets delivered
  • Checkout frustrations and UX breakdowns: Errors at payment, slow page loads, or poor mobile experience all sabotage conversions. Review heatmaps, bounce rates, and user feedback from tools like VWO or Lucky Orange
  • Low perceived value: If pricing feels high for what customers receive, it shows up in reviews and social commentary. Pay attention to words like “not worth it” or “overpriced” in feedback
  • Bad PR or viral negativity: Negative influencer reviews, Reddit threads, or TikTok call-outs can spiral quickly. Social listening is critical here – real-time awareness allows you to respond thoughtfully
  • Internal misalignment: A disconnected team often leads to a disjointed customer experience. Even employee reviews on Glassdoor affect how customers perceive your trustworthiness

The Top 10 Challenges Businesses Like Yours Face

These are the real struggles with Business Repuation that leaders talk to us about. We hear them all the time – and they are fixable.

A lot of public reviews are neutral or negative

  • Review all review sources where your business is listed
  • Send surveys to your customers asking for feedback
  • Ask customers who reviewed you positively to post a public review
  • Categorize review feedback by issue type and look for patterns
  • Send external review requests to customers who responded positively to your feedback request
  • Respond to negative reviews – acknowledge, own, and offer a resolution
  • Run a sentiment analysis to see emotional tone
  • Prioritize top two categories to address now
  • Consider setting up automation for review alerts

NPS score shows a lot more detractors than promoters

  • NPS alone isn’t the full story – look at open-ended feedback
  • Segment by product, location, or cohort to see where the breakdown is happening
  • Focus first on the biggest detractor group and ask what would need to change

Order fulfillment and shipping are common complaints

  • Audit your logistics providers – benchmark, track, and measure performance to ensure accuracy
  • Integrate accurate shipping times, in stock, and backordered item tagging on your website.
  • Implement a transactional fulfillment email flow with live tracking and proactive delay communication
  • Consider fulfillment auditing software or route optimization tools

The product is good but doesn’t deliver what they expected

  • Revisit product page copy and photography
  • Use real UGC (user generated content) to show the product in real use cases
  • Align marketing language with actual customer experience

    Customer Service is overwhelmed

    • Empower your team to make decisions without escalations
    • Use AI or automation to reduce ticket volume where possible
    • Focus on first contact resolution and personal connection

    Our Social Media blew up and we haven’t recovered

    • Don’t ignore it – address the issue honestly, even if it’s uncomfortable
    • Respond publicly and then move the conversation to private resolution
    • Keep receipts – screenshots of apologies and action steps build trust

    All of our reviews are from angry customers – happy customers don’t leave them.

    • Ask for reviews at the right moment – after a resolved issue or second purchase
    • Use email or SMS requests and make it easy
    • Offer incentives carefully (never pay for reviews, but a thank-you coupon is fine)

    We don’t really understand how our reputation compares to our competitors

    • Use tools like Brandwatch or Sprout to monitor sentiment by brand
    • Conduct competitor reviews audit – what are people praising them for?
    • Look at share of voice in social media mentions

    We’re so deep in the mess, we dont know where to start

    • Start with listening
    • Map the three biggest gaps between what your customers expect and what they experience
    • Make those your company’s top priorities this quarter

    Tools That Help Track, Monitor, Measure, and Repair

    These aren’t magic, but they give you the data and visibility to monitor your business reputation and lead with clarity.

    Tracking and Monitoring

    • Google Business Manager, Amazon Seller Central, and Trustpilot dashboards
    • Yext, BirdEye, and ReviewTrackers
    • Sprout Social, Mention, or Brand24 for social listening
    • Voice of the Customer Surveys, Interviews, or Focus Groups

    Measuring

    • Promoter.io Delighted or Hotjar for NPS and customer feedback
    • Google Analytics and FullStory for behavioral patterns
    • Jira or Zendesk for support ticket analytics

    Repair and Response

    • Podium or Reputation.com for review response workflows
    • Klaviyo or Attentive for post-purchase feedback automation
    • Canva and Later for UGC campaigns that rebuild public sentiment

    Real Stories of Business Reputations Rebuilt

    Yotpo turned its perception around in 136 days by facing criticism directly, revising its pricing communication, and making leadership more visible. They leaned into transparency and won back old clients.
    Read here →

    The Honest Company faced backlash over product safety and responded by auditing their entire ingredient lineup, increasing transparency, and rebuilding through education.
    Read here →

    KlearGear tried to fine a customer for a bad review – the internet and legal system had the last word. The business reputation never recovered.
    Read here →

    Final Thoughts – You Can Recover your Business Reputation

    A few bad reviews don’t define you. Even a whole year of missteps doesn’t make your company untrustworthy forever.

    When you lead with truth, take ownership, and align your systems with your values, your customers see it.

    Online business reputation management isn’t just about fixing bad PR. It’s about re-earning trust one experience at a time. With the right strategy, team buy-in, and tools in place, you can move from damage control to confidence.

    And that’s something worth building.

    Posted in General